top of page

Breakthrough new research rethinks sleep and consciousness

[Oct. 17, 2023: Staff Writer, The Brighter Side of News]

At night, as millions drift to sleep, a common belief persists: that sleep is a state of disconnection a retreat from the conscious world. (CREDIT: Creative Commons)

In the dead of night, as millions drift to sleep, a common belief persists: that sleep is a state of disconnection, a retreat from the conscious world into a sanctuary of rest and rejuvenation.

This notion, however, is on the brink of a revolutionary upheaval. A groundbreaking study from the Paris Brain Institute, led by neuroscientists Delphine Oudiette, Isabelle Arnulf, and Lionel Naccache, is challenging the traditional boundaries that separate wakefulness and sleep, revealing that our sleeping brains might be far more receptive to the external world than we've ever imagined.


This revolutionary research underscores that ordinary sleepers can indeed process verbal information delivered by a human voice during sleep, responding through facial muscle contractions. Astonishingly, this interaction with the external auditory stimulus isn't confined to a specific sleep phase; it intermittently spans almost all stages of sleep, suggesting sporadic moments when sleepers establish a connection with the outside world.

"The frontier between wakefulness and sleep appears much more porous than previously thought," states Delphine Oudiette, a cognitive neuroscience researcher involved in the study.


Related Stories


These findings not only reframe our understanding of sleep but also foreshadow the development of standardized communication protocols with sleeping individuals. The implications are profound, offering a potential new tool to delve into the cognitive processes underpinning both regular and abnormal sleep patterns.

"Sleep, despite being a nightly ritual, remains an intricate enigma," explains Lionel Naccache, a neurologist at Pitié-Salpêtrière University Hospital and a renowned neuroscientist. "Our research indicates that wakefulness and sleep aren't monolithic states but rather a mosaic of conscious and ostensibly unconscious instances."


Understanding the brain mechanisms that facilitate these intermediary states is pivotal. As Isabelle Arnulf, leader of the Sleep Pathology Department at Pitié-Salpêtrière University Hospital, points out, "Disruptions in these states can lead to conditions like sleepwalking, sleep paralysis, and vivid hallucinations, or subjective experiences like feeling awake throughout the night or paradoxically sleeping with open eyes."

Participants with narcolepsy went through five 20-min naps during the same day. In each nap, periods with stimulation (ON) alternated, every minute, with periods when no stimulus was presented (OFF). (CREDIT: Nature Neuroscience)

Traditionally, scientists have relied on physiological markers such as brain waves, visible through electroencephalography (EEG), to differentiate between wakefulness and various sleep stages. These indicators, albeit useful, fall short of painting a comprehensive picture of the sleeper's mental experiences and sometimes even clash with their accounts. "We require more refined physiological measurements that resonate with the sleepers' experiences to accurately determine their alertness levels during sleep," Oudiette emphasizes.


Unveiling the Dance Between Unconsciousness and Awareness

To further investigate this intricate interplay between sleep and consciousness, the research team embarked on an innovative approach. They assembled a group comprising 22 healthy individuals and 27 patients diagnosed with narcolepsy, a condition marked by uncontrollable bouts of daytime sleepiness.

Accurate behavioral responses in both populations. The overall response rate across different sleep stages during OFF (blue) and ON (green) stimulation periods in participants without (left) and with (right) narcolepsy. (CREDIT: Nature Neuroscience)

Intriguingly, those with narcolepsy often have numerous lucid dreams, showing an acute awareness of their dreaming state and occasionally even controlling their dream narratives. Their propensity to rapidly enter REM sleep—the phase closely associated with lucid dreaming—during daylight hours, makes them ideal subjects for studying sleep consciousness under experimental setups.


"In a prior study, we discovered that bi-directional communication is feasible during lucid REM sleep," Oudiette notes. "This prompted us to question whether such interactions could extend to other sleep stages and to individuals who don't experience lucid dreams."

Lucidity is associated with longer reaction times and increased responsiveness. Distribution of reaction times from stimulus onset to response in correct trials (words and pseudowords) in NP across sleep stages. Dashed lines indicate medians. (CREDIT: Nature Neuroscience)

The study's protocol was meticulously designed. Participants were instructed to nap while undergoing a "lexical decision" test, where a human voice articulated a series of genuine and fabricated words. The response was instinctive yet profound; participants were to smile or frown to classify the words. Concurrently, their physiological parameters—including brain and heart activities, eye movements, and muscle tone—were rigorously documented via polysomnography. Upon awakening, they recounted their experiences, specifying any occurrences of lucid dreams or interactions.


"Remarkably, most participants, regardless of narcolepsy, accurately responded to the verbal cues while ostensibly asleep," Arnulf reports. "Although these instances were more prevalent during lucid dreams, indicative of elevated consciousness, they sporadically manifested across all sleep stages in both cohorts."

Participants exhibit sleep activity in responsive trials, with local brain activations associated with responsiveness. Time–frequency analysis (TFA) performed on the Fp1 (top) and the O1 (bottom) electrodes in N2 (23 nonresponsive participants and 21 responsive participants) and REM sleep (15 nonresponsive participants and 14 responsive participants) of NP. (CREDIT: Nature Neuroscience)

Redefining the Concept of Disconnected Sleep

The researchers’ innovative methodology of correlating physiological and behavioral data with subjective narratives led to another startling discovery: the potential to foresee when these "windows of connectivity" with the external environment open. These episodes, where sleepers could respond to stimuli, were preceded by a surge in brain activity and physiological markers typically linked with intense cognitive operations.


"In subjects who experienced lucid dreams, the capacity to process verbal cues and subsequently recall this interaction upon waking was distinguished by a unique electrophysiological signature," Naccache reveals. "Our data implies that lucid dreamers possess an enhanced connection to their internal world, and this heightened consciousness permeates to external surroundings."

EEG markers of high cognitive states computed before stimulus presentation vary with responsiveness to stimuli. (CREDIT: Nature Neuroscience)

While these findings are transformative, further exploration is required to ascertain if the frequency of these responsive windows correlates with sleep quality or if they can be harnessed to ameliorate sleep disorders or even facilitate learning during sleep. "Utilizing sophisticated neuroimaging methods, like magnetoencephalography and intracranial recordings of brain functions, will be instrumental in decrypting the brain orchestration behind these sleeper interactions," Oudiette asserts.


These revelations compel us to reassess the very definition of sleep. What if sleep isn't a state of total disconnection and passive rest, but an active state, more conscious and interactive than previously conceived? This research opens a new frontier, challenging our understanding of consciousness and its relationship with the world around us—even when we're enveloped in the arms of sleep.

With the relentless march of scientific inquiry, the night's silent hours may no longer signify a disconnect from the world but a different mode of connection, a realm where the mind, though asleep, maintains a subtle, discerning link to the world beyond. The revelations by Oudiette, Arnulf, Naccache, and their team are not just a scientific breakthrough; they are a philosophical, psychological, and existential reevaluation of what it means to be human, to sleep, and to dream.

For more science news stories check out our New Discoveries section at The Brighter Side of News.


Note: Materials provided above by The Brighter Side of News. Content may be edited for style and length.


Like these kind of feel good stories? Get the Brighter Side of News' newsletter.


Most Recent Stories

bottom of page