Do benefits of physical, mental activity on thinking differ for men and women?
[July 24, 2022: Natalie Conrad, American Academy of Neurology]
The study looked at the effects of physical and mental activities, such as reading, going to classes, or playing cards or games, on cognitive reserve in the areas of thinking speed and memory. (CREDIT: Creative Commons)
Studies have shown that physical and mental activity help preserve thinking skills and delay dementia. A new study suggests that these benefits may vary for men and women. The study is published in the online issue of Neurology®, the medical journal of the American Academy of Neurology.
The study looked at the effects of physical and mental activities, such as reading, going to classes, or playing cards or games, on cognitive reserve in the areas of thinking speed and memory. Cognitive reserve is the buffer that occurs when people have strong thinking skills even when their brains show signs of the underlying changes associated with cognitive impairment and dementia.
“We found that greater physical activity was associated with greater thinking speed reserve in women, but not in men,” said study author Judy Pa, PhD, of the University of California, San Diego. “Taking part in more mental activities was associated with greater thinking speed reserve for both men and women.”
Greater physical activity was not associated with memory reserve in men or women.
The study involved 758 people with an average age of 76. Some had no thinking or memory problems, some had mild cognitive impairment, and some had dementia. The participants had brain scans and took thinking speed and memory tests.
To calculate cognitive reserve, people’s thinking tests scores were compared against the changes in the brain associated with dementia, such as the total volume of the hippocampus, a key brain region impacted by Alzheimer’s disease.
People were also asked about their usual weekly physical activity. For mental activity, they were asked whether they participated in three types of activities in the past 13 months: reading magazines, newspapers or books; going to classes; and playing cards, games or bingo. They were given one point for each type of activity, for a maximum of three points.
For mental activity, participants averaged 1.4 points. For physical activity, participants took part in an average of at least 15 minutes per week of activities that elevate heart rates such as brisk walking and biking.
Pa said that each additional mental activity people participated in corresponded to 13 fewer years of aging in their processing speed in their thinking skills—17 years among men and 10 years among women.
“As we have arguably few-to-no effective treatments for Alzheimer’s disease, prevention is crucial. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of treatment,” Pa said. “To know that people could potentially improve their cognitive reserve by taking simple steps such as going to classes at the community center, playing bingo with their friends or spending more time walking or gardening is very exciting.”
Pa said that based on the effect sizes seen in the study, a doubling of the amount of physical activity would be equivalent to an estimated 2.75 fewer years of aging when it comes to women’s processing speed in their thinking skills.
Researchers also looked at whether the relationship between physical and mental activities and cognitive reserve was affected by the gene that carries the strongest risk for Alzheimer’s, called APOE e4. They found that for women, having the gene lessens the effects of the beneficial relationship between physical and mental activities and cognitive reserve.
Association between Physical (METS) and Cognitive (COGACT) Activities and Speed and Memory Reserve. The (added variable) plots demonstrate the association between METS and Speed and Memory Reserves (A, B) and between COGACT and Speed and Memory Reserves (C, D) stratified by sex by regressing out the covariates from both the dependent and independent variables in each panel. (CREDIT: Effects of Sex, APOE4, and Lifestyle Activities on Cognitive Reserve in Older Adults - Neurology.org)
The study does not prove that physical and mental activities help improve cognitive reserve. It only shows an association.
A limitation of the study was that people reported their own physical and mental activity, so they may not have remembered correctly. Also, structural and societal factors that affect cognitive reserve, such as education, were not measured in the study.
The study was supported by the National Institute on Aging and the National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences.
For more science news stories check out our New Discoveries section at The Brighter Side of News.
Note: Materials provided above by American Academy of Neurology. Content may be edited for style and length.
Like these kind of feel good stories? Get the Brighter Side of News' newsletter.